MYGA vs. CD: Is There A Smarter Choice for Your Savings?

Interest rates have been elevated for the last few years, and if long term U.S. Treasury rates are any indicator, they will remain elevated at or above pre-pandemic levels for the foreseeable future. 

Banks know this and are planning on this continued interest rate direction.  Walk into almost any retail bank branch today and you'll be greeted with a poster promising a "guaranteed" certificate of deposit rate that sounds too good to pass up. For savers who want safety and predictability, especially those in or near retirement, a bank CD can feel like the obvious, no-risk choice. But there's another guaranteed, low-risk savings vehicle that often gets overlooked in that conversation, and it can leave significantly more money in your pocket over time: the multi-year guaranteed annuity, or MYGA.

Many clients, existing and prospective have never compared the structural differences of a MYGA to a CD. Most people default to a CD simply because it's familiar. But once a client understands how the two instruments actually compare on rates, tax treatment, access to funds, and what happens to the accumulated savings when one passes away; the decision often looks much less obvious.

What Is a MYGA, exactly?

A multi-year guaranteed annuity is a contract issued by an insurance company that guarantees a fixed interest rate for a set period, typically anywhere from three to ten years. Titan Brokerage only offers MYGA’s that are classified by major ratings companies as “A” rated which is important for the client’s evaluation of the financial strength of the underlying company he or she wishes to deposit funds with. In practice, a MYGA behaves a lot like a CD: one can generally deposit a lump sum of money, lock a guaranteed rate in for the selected term and protect the principal deposit from any interest rate market swings. The similarities end, though, when one looks at how each product treats the accumulated growth upon principal during the term duration and the treatment of beneficiaries if something happens to the owner.

How a Bank CD Works

A certificate of deposit is a savings product offered by banks and credit unions. One deposits their money for a fixed term in exchange for a fixed interest rate that is generally linked to the performance of the Federal Funds Effective Rate.

The deposit is insured by the FDIC for up to $250,000 per depositor, per institution. That insurance backing is valuable justification for considering CDs for it can create the perception of being the safer, more familiar option over other available fixed interest savings instruments. What most CD holders don't fully account for, however, is how the interest payment made by the bank and/or credit union every year is taxed.  Every year, interest payments are taxed as ordinary income, whether or not one ever accesses the initial deposit one makes into the CD thus lowering the overall tax-effective yield offered by CDs.

The Tax-Deferral Difference That Changes the Math

This is where the comparison starts to tilt. With a CD, the IRS treats interest as taxable income the year it's credited to an account, even if every dollar of interest is reinvested and the client never makes a withdrawal. Bank and Credit Union Clients receive a 1099-INT at the end of each calendar year and owe tax on that interest growth. 

A MYGA works differently. Because it's an annuity, the interest it earns grows tax deferred. A client that has deposited into a MYGA does not owe a dime in taxes until one withdraws funds, whether that's at maturity, through annual withdrawals, or when one eventually annuitizes the contract. That single difference can be worth more than it sounds. Consider a $100,000 deposit earning 5% annually over a five-year term for someone in the 24% tax bracket. In a CD, that annual tax drag reduces the effective compounding rate every year, so the account grows to roughly $124,000 after taxes are paid along the way. In a MYGA earning the same 5%, with no annual tax obligation, the account compounds to more than $127,000 by maturity, with taxes owed only once one accesses the money. That's thousands of dollars in additional growth from tax treatment alone, and the gap widens the longer the money stays invested and the higher the client’s tax bracket.

Rate Competitiveness: MYGAs Often Win Here Too

It isn't only about taxes. In the current rate environment, MYGA rates from many carriers are running meaningfully higher than comparable-term CDs, sometimes by half a percentage point or more. Banks set CD rates based on the Federal Funds Effective Rate in addition to their own funding needs and profit margins. Large national banks in particular are often far less competitive than smaller regional banks or credit unions. Insurance carriers competing for MYGA business, on the other hand, are frequently offering more attractive guaranteed rates to bring in deposits. When combining a higher headline rate with the tax-deferral advantage, the total growth difference between a MYGA and a CD of the same term can be substantial.

What Happens to the Money When You Pass Away

This is a feature that rarely comes up in a bank teller's pitch, but it matters significantly for anyone thinking about estate planning. With a MYGA, a client can name a beneficiary directly on the contract. When you pass away, the full accumulated value transfers straight to that person, bypassing probate entirely. There's no waiting on the courts, no attorney fees chipping away at the balance, and no delay for loved ones receiving what the client intended for them.

A bank CD doesn't offer that same protection unless it specifically includes a payable-on-death, or POD, designation. Without one, the CD becomes part of the client’s estate and typically has to go through probate before heirs see a dollar of the proceeds. That process can take months and often comes with legal costs that reduce what ultimately reaches beneficiaries.

Access to Your Money

A common concern with any term oriented savings product is what happens if a client needs access to their money early. Bank CDs are notoriously inflexible here: withdraw before maturity and one typically forfeits a chunk of the interest one has earned, often anywhere from ninety to one hundred eighty days' worth, with no partial withdrawal options.

Most MYGAs are actually more forgiving. It's standard for a MYGA to allow a penalty-free withdrawal of up to 10% of the account value each year after the first year and in some cases on day 2, without triggering any surrender charge. If an unexpected expense comes up, one has a built-in escape valve that a CD simply doesn't provide. Surrender charges on the remaining balance do decline year by year over the contract term, further reducing the cost of accessing funds later in the term if needed.

What About FDIC Insurance vs. Guaranty Association Coverage?

This is the one area where CDs have a clear structural edge, and it's worth addressing directly rather than glossing over it. CDs are backed by FDIC insurance, a federal program, up to $250,000 per depositor per bank. MYGAs are backed by the financial strength of the issuing insurance company and, as a secondary layer of protection, by state guaranty associations, which typically cover between $100,000 and $250,000 depending on the state. For most savers, that coverage is more than sufficient, and just as you might spread a large sum across multiple banks to stay under FDIC limits, you can spread a large MYGA allocation across multiple insurance carriers to maximize guaranty coverage. It's also worth choosing carriers with strong financial strength ratings, since that underlying stability is what ultimately backs your guarantee.

Other Advantages Worth Knowing

A few additional features round out the case for MYGAs. Accounts designated non-qualified for tax purposes, are eligible to receive 1035 exchanges from other annuity contracts, allowing a client to move funds between annuities from various insurance companies without triggering a taxable event, something a CD simply cannot accommodate. In some states, annuities also receive partial or full exemption from Medicaid asset look-back calculations, which can matter for long-term care and estate planning. And because MYGAs are one of the simplest types of annuities available as each have no market exposure, no intricate riders, and no variable returns, they carry none of the complexity that sometimes give annuities a bad reputation.

Which Savings Vehicle Is Best?

The simple answer is neither. Both CDs and MYGAs serve the same basic purpose: preserving principal while earning a guaranteed, predictable return. If FDIC insurance is a non-negotiable requirement for you, or you need every dollar to remain completely liquid with zero surrender considerations, a CD may make sense for a portion of your savings. However, if one is considering a strategy for savings purely on growth potential, tax efficiency, and what happens to the money for beneficiaries in the event of the owner’s passing, a MYGA frequently comes out ahead, particularly for money one would not need to access for several years.

Before renewing a CD or locking in a new one at a bank, it's worth taking a few minutes to run the numbers on a comparable MYGA. The rate advertised at the branch is rarely the truly realized rate received once taxes and beneficiary treatments are factored in. A conversation with a licensed financial professional who has access to current MYGA rates across multiple carriers can help clients see exactly how much more money could be working for them, and for the beneficiaries they eventually want it to go to.

Frequently Asked Questions